Want to create an interactive transcript for this episode?
Podcast: Mind Behind The Crime | The Psychology Of Killers
Episode: Eleven Felonies. One Year. The Psychology Behind a System That Protects Predators | Jesse Butler Case
Description: How does someone charged with eleven felonies — including rape and strangulation — walk away with a single year of supervision? In Stillwater, Oklahoma, 17-year-old Jesse Mack Butler attacked two teenage girls so brutally one nearly died. Police had video evidence. Doctors confirmed near-fatal injuries. Yet the court called it “rehabilitation.”
In this episode, Tony Brueski and psychotherapist Shavaun Scott unpack the psychology of protection — the denial, privilege, and misplaced empathy that let predators slip through the cracks. From family complicity to small-town bias, this is a case study in how justice fails survivors — and what it says about our collective mo...