Film critics William Bibbiani and Witney Seibold host a series of ongoing shows, featuring CRITICALLY ACCLAIMED (new movie reviews), THANK GODZILLA IT'S FRIDAY, CANCELED TOO SOON, WE'VE GOT MAIL, THE IRON LIST, and more!
The Iron List #75 | Every John Carpenter Movie Ever!
185 hours 57 mins; March 29, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #362 | Project Hail Mary, Undertone, Ready or Not: Here I Come, Reminders of Him, The Gates
89 hours 35 mins; March 24, 2026
We've Got Mail #192 | You Know What You Did!
96 hours 58 mins; March 20, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #361 | The 98th Annual Oscars Autopsy
99 hours 4 mins; March 17, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #360 | Hoppers, The Bride!, Dolly, Heel, War Machine, Gunfighter Paradise
93 hours 1 min; March 09, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #359 | Scream 7, The Bluff, Psycho Killer, The Dreadful
94 hours 13 mins; March 02, 2026
The Iron List #74 | The Best Movies of 1999!
193 hours 51 mins; February 27, 2026
SNACKFAM! Do You Like Crunchies? (Lay's Salted Caramel Chips)
30 mins; February 25, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #358 | The 98th Annual Oscar-Nominated Short Films!
132 hours 54 mins; February 20, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #357 | Wuthering Heights, Good Luck Have Fun Don't Die, Goat, Crime 101, Nirvanna The Band The Show, The Movie, By Design, Cold Storage
110 hours 45 mins; February 17, 2026
We've Got Mail #191 | What Should YOU Watch on Criterion Channel?
77 hours 0 mins; February 12, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #356 | Send Help, Melania, Iron Lung, The Strangers - Chapter 3, Whistle, The Wrecking Crew, Relationship Goals, Solo Mio, Pillion, Shelter
143 hours 57 mins; February 10, 2026
The All-Nighter | Valentine's Day 2026 Movie Marathons!
130 hours 58 mins; February 08, 2026
We've Got Mail #190 | Was TV's 'The Critic' a Good Critic?
88 hours 7 mins; February 04, 2026
The Iron List #73 | The Best Cinematography Ever!
168 hours 38 mins; January 29, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #355 | The 98th Oscar Nominations, Mercy, 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple, The Rip, A Useful Ghost, Sound of Falling, H is for Hawk
106 hours 48 mins; January 27, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #354 | Marty Supreme, Primate, Anaconda, The Testament of Ann Lee, Song Sung Blue, Father Mother Sister Brother, Greenland 2: Migration, Dead Man's Wire, The Plague, All That's Left of You, The Dutchman
146 hours 39 mins; January 12, 2026
We've Got Mail #189 | Jesse, Listen to Your Grandmother!
89 hours 24 mins; January 05, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #353 | The Worst and Most Average Movies of 2025!
131 hours 17 mins; January 01, 2026
Critically Acclaimed #352 | Bibbs and Witney's Best Movies of 2025!
182 hours 13 mins; December 28, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #351 | Avatar: Fire and Ash, The Housemaid, Ella McCay, The Spongebob Movie: Search for SquarePants, Goodbye June, Silent Night Deadly Night, Scarlet, Influencers, Not Without Hope
125 hours 31 mins; December 22, 2025
We've Got Mail #188 | Soup Movies?!?!
69 hours 21 mins; December 19, 2025
The Iron List #72 | The Best "This Had Oscar Buzz" Movies Ever!
154 hours 42 mins; December 15, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #350 | The Secret Agent, Five Nights at Freddy's 2, Merrily We Roll Along, The Chronology of Water, Oh. What. Fun., Fackham Hall, 100 Nights of Hero, Rosemead
118 hours 26 mins; December 07, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #349 | Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery, Hamnet, Zootopia 2, Jingle Bell Heist
95 hours 39 mins; December 01, 2025
The Iron List #71 | The Coziest Movies Ever Made!
153 hours 42 mins; November 28, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #348 | Wicked: For Good, Rental Family, Reflection in a Dead Diamond, Sisu: Road to Revenge, Champagne Problems
82 hours 0 mins; November 25, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #347 | The Running Man, Now You See Me: Now You Don't, Nouvelle Vague, Arco, Lesbian Space Princess, Keeper, The Carpenter's Son, A Very Jonas Christmas Movie, A Merry Little Ex-Mas
134 hours 32 mins; November 17, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #346 | Predator: Badlands, Sentimental Value, Bugonia, Nuremberg, Die My Love, Ballad of a Small Player, In Your Dreams, Christy
122 hours 6 mins; November 10, 2025
We've Got Mail #187 | OMG, Heathcliff Knows Who We Are!
69 hours 9 mins; November 01, 2025
The All-Nighter | Halloween 2025 Movie Marathons!
98 hours 42 mins; October 29, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #345 | Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein, Black Phone 2, Shelby Oaks, A House of Dynamite, The Twits, Chainsaw Man - THe Movie: Reze Arc, Hedda, The Hand That Rocks the Cradle, Queens of the Dead
147 hours 2 mins; October 27, 2025
This Ain't No Game #2 | Star Trek: The Golden Trivia Game (1985)
94 hours 4 mins; October 23, 2025
The Iron List #70 | The Best Vampire Movies Ever!
159 hours 12 mins; October 20, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #344 | Tron: Ares, Deathstalker, Good Boy, The Smashing Machine, Play Dirty, After the Hunt, Anemone, Orwell: 2+2=5, Vicious, 100 Meters
144 hours 26 mins; October 14, 2025
This Ain't No Game #1 | Trivial Pursuit: Silver Screen Edition (1983)
80 hours 28 mins; October 03, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #343 | One Battle After Another, Him, A Big Bold Beautiful Journey, Listers: A Glimpse into Extreme Birdwatching, The Lost Bus, Dead of Winter, The Strangers: Chapter 2
127 hours 46 mins; September 29, 2025
The Iron Liszt #69 | The Best Film Scores Ever!
145 hours 3 mins; September 25, 2025
We've Got Mail #186 | Is Sinners a Horror Movie? (Yes!)
82 hours 6 mins; September 22, 2025
Alonso Duralde, Have Yourself a Movie Little Christmas! | The Critically Acclaimed Interview
70 hours 42 mins; September 18, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #342 | The Conjuring: Last Rites, The Long Walk, Spinal Tap II, The History of Sound, Twinless, The History of Sound
89 hours 23 mins; September 15, 2025
We've Got Mail #185 | The Trans Characters Who Mean the World to Us
80 hours 29 mins; September 08, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #341 | The Toxic Avenger, Caught Stealing, The Roses, The Thursday Murder Club
84 hours 57 mins; September 02, 2025
The Iron List #68 | The Best Horror Movies of 1990!
152 hours 35 mins; August 28, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #340 | Relay, Honey Don't!, Eenie Meanie, Devo, The Map That Leads to You
91 hours 46 mins; August 25, 2025
We've Got Mail #184 | Whither Goest the Great Disney Villains?
82 hours 8 mins; August 21, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #339 | Highest 2 Lowest, Nobody 2, Red Sonja, Fixed, East of Wall
86 hours 29 mins; August 18, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #338 | Weapons, Freakier Friday, Souleymane's Story, Sketch, It's Never Over Jeff Buckley
106 hours 12 mins; August 10, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #337 | The Fantastic Four: First Steps, The Naked Gun, The Bad Guys 2, The Home, Together, She Rides Shotgun, My Oxford Year, War of the Worlds
126 hours 27 mins; August 04, 2025
The Iron List #67 | The Best Westerns Ever!
168 hours 25 mins; July 28, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #336 | I Know What You Did Last Summer, Eddington, My Mom Jane
95 hours 25 mins; July 21, 2025
We've Got Mail #183 | Emotional Support Cats?!
80 hours 6 mins; July 17, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #335 | Superman, Jurassic World Rebirth, KPop Demon Hunters, Hot Spring Shark Attack, The Old Guard 2, Kill the Jockey, Abraham's Boys, To a Land Unknown, Sovereign, Apocalypse in the Tropics
135 hours 28 mins; July 14, 2025
Star Trek: Section 31 (2025) | The Critically Acclaimed Commentary Track
93 hours 58 mins; June 30, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #334 | Elio, How to Train Your Dragon, 28 Years Later, Bride Hard, Materialists, Everything's Going to Be Great, The Unholy Trinity, F1 The Movie
116 hours 17 mins; June 24, 2025
The Iron List #66 | The Best Road Trip Movies Ever!
156 hours 15 mins; June 21, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #333 | From the World of John Wick: Ballerina, Predator: Killer of Killers, The Life of Chuck, Dangerous Animals, Echo Valley
90 hours 33 mins; June 11, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #332 | Karate Kid: Legends, The Phoenician Scheme, Bring Her Back
75 hours 10 mins; June 02, 2025
We've Got Mail #182 | When is Jarnathan Getting Here?
58 mins; May 30, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #331 | Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning, Hurry Up Tomorrow, Lilo & Stitch, Fountain of Youth, Final Destination: Bloodlines, Fear Street: Prom Queen
128 hours 37 mins; May 26, 2025
We've Got Mail #181 | Noir vs. Neo-Noir
71 hours 45 mins; May 23, 2025
The Iron List #65 | The Best Movies That Begin with the Letter "L"
156 hours 8 mins; May 19, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #330 | Clown in a Cornfield, Fight or Flight, Absolute Dominion, Summer of 69, Juliet & Romeo
107 hours 17 mins; May 12, 2025
The Iron List #64 | The Best Ragtag Team of Misfits Movies
Critically Acclaimed #328 | Sinners, Until Dawn, Havoc, On Swift Horses, Dead Mail, Sneaks
108 hours 43 mins; April 28, 2025
We've Got Mail #180 | The P.O. Box Awakens! The Crimson Dynamo, Zines and More!
80 hours 23 mins; April 21, 2025
We've Got Mail #179 | Can the Halloween Franchise Be Saved?
74 hours 31 mins; April 18, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #327 | The Amateur, Drop, G20, Warfare, The King of Kings, One to One: John and Yoko
95 hours 12 mins; April 14, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #326 | A Minecraft Movie, Screamboat, The Luckiest Man in America, Hell of a Summer
88 hours 35 mins; April 07, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #325 | Snow White, The Woman in the Yard, The Alto Knights, O'Dessa, The Penguin Lessons, Popeye the Slayer Man, Ash
112 hours 22 mins; April 01, 2025
The Iron List #63 | The Best Knockoff Movies Ever!
149 hours 16 mins; March 27, 2025
We've Got Mail #178 | What Are Our Favorite Pokemon?!
86 hours 57 mins; March 24, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #324 | The Electric State, The Day the Earth Blew Up, The Rule of Jenny Pen, Black Bag, Mickey 17, Novocaine, Night of the Zoopocalypse, Opus, On Becoming a Guinea Fowl, Queen of the Ring, My Dead Friend Zoe, The Parenting
145 hours 50 mins; March 17, 2025
Canceled Too Soon #264 | Spicy City (1997) w/ M. Lopes Da Silva!
111 hours 36 mins; March 15, 2025
The Iron List #62 | The Worst Movies of the 21st Century (So Far)!
175 hours 54 mins; March 07, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #323 | Oscar Shorts and Predictions 2025!
148 hours 39 mins; February 28, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #322 | Captain America: Brave New World, The Monkey, The Gorge, Bridget Jones: Mad About the Boy, The Dead Thing, Cleaner
106 hours 9 mins; February 24, 2025
Canceled Too Soon #263 | The Oblongs (2001-2002) w/ Chelsea Spirito!
141 hours 30 mins; February 16, 2025
We've Got Mail #177 | Should We Make MORE Star Trek Podcasts?
79 hours 0 mins; February 14, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #321 | Heart Eyes, Love Hurts, Kinda Pregnant
89 hours 27 mins; February 10, 2025
Critically Acclaimed: The Best Movies of the 21st Century (So Far)!
203 hours 49 mins; February 06, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #320 | Star Trek: Section 31, Dog Man, Companion, Presence, Love Me
99 hours 51 mins; February 03, 2025
We've Got Mail #176 | The Tom Cruise Mummy Remake: Will History Be Kind?
97 hours 23 mins; January 27, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #319 | Wolf Man, Emilia Perez, Wallace and Gromit: Vengeance Most Fowl, Grand Theft Hamlet, The Last Showgirl, I'm Still Here, Hard Truths, Wish You Were Here, Diane Warren: Relentless
121 hours 32 mins; January 24, 2025
Critically Acclaimed: The David Lynch Tribute
134 hours 29 mins; January 20, 2025
Canceled Too Soon #262 | Gilligan's Planet (1982)
119 hours 55 mins; January 09, 2025
The Iron List #61 | The Best Movies of 1985!
143 hours 57 mins; January 06, 2025
Critically Acclaimed #318 | The Best, Worst and Averagest Movies of 2024!
185 hours 26 mins; December 31, 2024
Critically Acclaimed #317 | A Complete Unknown, Better Man, Mufasa: The Lion King, The Fire Inside, The Brutalist, Nosferatu, Babygirl, Homestead
137 hours 38 mins; December 27, 2024
The Iron List #60 | The Best Movies That Begin with the Letter K!
159 hours 36 mins; December 20, 2024
Critically Acclaimed #316 | The Lord of the Rings: The War of the Rohirrim, Kraven the Hunter, Carry-On, That Christmas, Nightbitch, Nickel Boys, The End, September 5
130 hours 37 mins; December 16, 2024
Canceled Too Soon #259 | The Idiot Box (1991)
104 hours 25 mins; December 13, 2024
We've Got Mail #175 | How Awesome is Sum 41?!
73 hours 48 mins; December 09, 2024
All Our Yesterdays: Star Trek Deep Space Nine - Emissary
103 hours 16 mins; December 06, 2024
Critically Acclaimed #315 | Moana 2, Queer, The Seed of the Sacred Fig, September 5
91 hours 29 mins; December 02, 2024
Canceled Too Soon #258 | Cool and Lam (1958)
66 hours 0 mins; November 28, 2024
Critically Acclaimed #314 | Wicked, Gladiator II, Red One, Hot Frosty, The Piano Lesson, Flow, The World According to Allee Willis
